I already have an excellent clean up crew and the tank has been cycled with old media. It doesn’t clean the water or have any beneficial properties? My experience with carbon has always been a positive but un-neccessary step in filtering a tank. They do. Thread starter langer! Wouldn't really say that plants absorb odors and absorb medications... Well the purpose of carbon and purigen is to form chemical bonds with compounds, nutrients, etc in the water, thus removing them from the water column. Let's say you have a, Well the purpose of carbon and purigen is to form chemical bonds with compounds, nutrients, etc in the water, thus removing them from the water column. Handbollsspelare landslaget. I was looking into a canister filter for my 45 and decided not to get one because they're so much money. Water Chemistry . 8 Personen fanden diese Informationen hilfreich . The tank skimmer collects these proteins before they break down and keeps your aquarium environment safe and healthy. As it adsorbs waste products, Purigen® will change color from a pale blonde to a dark brown, almost black. This is a similar debate in the freshwater world, as many claim carbon removes some nutrients consumed by planted tanks. royal priče, astrologija,kineska astrologija, asteroidi, film, magazin The only advantage Purigen has over Carbon that it can be recycle/recharge. Specific Planted Tank Discussions. As far as Chemi-Pure, Chemi-Pure made me a … This article describes my personal method for recharging the product. For me, Purigen is pretty much a must-have. Purigen and activated carbon vs fertilizers: Planted Tanks: Jul 17, 2019: Purigen recharge: General Discussions: Mar 21, 2019: Wanted: Seachem Equilibrium & Purigen net: Wanted/Swop/Freebies: Jul 19, 2018: Wanted: Seachem purigen: Wanted/Swop/Freebies: Sep 5, 2017: Where to add Seachem Purigen/Matrix to Eheim 350 pro? how to use purigen in sump. It seems to me that Purigen offers many of the benefits that activated carbon touts, but it works with your fertilizers and it cost less in the long run. Purigen® can also be regenerated. The only advantage Purigen has over Carbon that it can be recycle/recharge. A forum community dedicated to Aquatic tank owners and enthusiasts. *Purigen removes many tannins and other organic water "yellowing" by-products that ordinary carbon or carbon based products cannot (this is especially helpful to use with new driftwood or to lower the "yellow" color of aquarium 2-3 days after introduction of Indian Almond Leaves or Peat). Reply Like Reply. I've ran Purigen for 2 months on my planted tank, and my plants are extremely healthy and growing like weeds. Just a guess. I guess I'll give Purigen a try, my tank is already crystal clear but doesn't hurt to make it clearer =). Purigen is a premium macro-porous synthetic polymer and an organic filtration resin that is able to remove soluble and insoluble impurities from your fish tank water. What is the purpose of adding one or the other? This article describes my personal method for recharging the product. So, some of my tanks has Amquel and others has Prime. Filtration : Jun 30, 2015: Purigen … Same tank has now been running for nearly a year with Purigen. Fish Lore's aquarium forum - aquarium hobbyists helping hobbyists since 2005! Digital mobning undersøgelse. I am guessing in the 75 I would remove one of The carbons and put the purigen in one of The slots instead. If your planted aquarium is experiencing a significant buildup of phosphate, it is recommended to investigate your system for a carbon (CO2), nitrogen, or potassium deficiency. Carbon will end it life once it's being used up. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. I am in the process of switching from Amquel to Prime (cheaper). What is the purpose of adding one or the other? Sweet … 30. The main difference between carbon and every other chemical filtration media is carbon gets spent much faster and once spent can release bad stuff back into the water. I think purigen is better but they only last little longer than carbon. Share: Facebook Twitter Reddit Pinterest WhatsApp Email Link. The issue I can see, is it may remove some nutrients that the plants utilize. NickAu. Expertfreetips. Peat Balls vs Purigen. How does carbon polish water? Start date 9 Oct 2014; L. langer! I'm not real big on these products. Thread starter langer! Purigen, if used, should be placed at the end of the chamber to capture the finest particles before water re-enters the tank. This set is compact and convenient to set up in a small to medium-sized aquarium. Eyvind hellstrøm. Ive been looking into putting in either Chemipure, purigen, or carbon in my 29g anemone tank. Originally had him in a 20 gallon tank and felt bad he was living in such a cramped tank. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. I do a recharge every couple of weeks, when it’s a light brown colour. Some hobbyists will tell you it’s completely useless and it’s one way of seeing it, but it’s not completely true. Specific Planted Tank Discussions. I have a 55 gallon tank and I have two filters. SEACHEM Purigen® is a premium synthetic adsorbent. 9 Oct 2014 #1 Hello, was just wondering what you guys prefer to use, or any benefit of one over the other. It says “For17 Jun 2017 Regeneration: Soak in a 1:1 bleach:water solution for 24 hours in a non-metalic container in a … Gratis Versand durch Amazon schon ab 29€. Overall, I would definitely recommend this product to anyone looking to replace their filter media, upgrade their filter or to those who want to start a planted tank (filters such as activated carbon will remove any fertilizers you put in the tank but Seachem Purigen doesn't seem like it does so it's not counter productive when you're putting in your ferts). I have one tank 80 U.S. gallon's that ran for a year heavily planted without the use of Purigen. It is based on my experience and a pH crash in a small tank that was duplicated and verified by Seachem, causing a change to the product label and me getting a bunch of free stuff. Activated carbon can remove trace elements, so I think Purigen is a way better option. I plan to replace Biomax gradually ovver time with Biohole Ultimate Mini filter media. If you are cycling, it will probably slow things down a fair bit, until it becomes exhausted. Probably why it costs more. Lesen Sie weiter. A: It is superior to carbon in removing organics and not having negative impacts, but it is also compatible with carbon. But geez, I would love some of that crystal clarity in my planted aquarium. 2,981 3.0K. Also, I would think this stuff strips certain nutrients out of the water that my plants need. Probably actually works out to like 8 gallons. I researched about purigen and carbon. The thing is, you … Therefor I run Purigen instead, however they are both claimed to remove organic compounds (not in-organic). Carbons made from coconut shell and other organic products form microporous carbons, while carbons made from bituminous coal form macroporous carbons. This is a similar debate in the freshwater world, as many claim carbon removes some nutrients consumed by planted tanks. Purigen is so far the leading water filtration product that completely removes organic waste from water and hence ensures purity in water by eliminating any chances of ammonia, nitrites, and nitrates being left in the water. Some people run Purigen and Chemipure together as well even though they do the same thing. 28 Feb 2015 Regenerating Seachem Purigen 189976 – in Cleaning and There is an extra step in the directions that doesn’t make sense to me! Both do in some way, but are not necessary in a healthy, cycled aquarium. Purigen® generally ignores simple elemental compounds, having an extreme affinity for nitrogenous organics. The Purigen pouches were retired to a storage bin. So I'm having a minor issue with some Black Beard Algae (a.k.a Black Brush Algae). Perhap's … The Making Of The Purifier reef2reef.com . Good husbandry is our responsibility and if carbon filtration is something you feel you need, filter away. I was never able to get my water as clear as I can with Purigen, and I don't have to touch/change it NEARLY as much as carbon. Also, I would think this stuff strips certain nutrients out of the water that my plants need. Then cover and fasten the air outlet (positioned on the top side of the diffuser) … Seachem Matrix vs. Seachem Purigen? Firstly absolutely agree to stop with carbon it’s a waste of money and only needed when your removing medication and chemicals from your tank and should only be used for a week or so max. Jessica Belmont. If you are using Matrix for the first time, the 32 ppm will increase by the time you do the next water change due to new organic wastes produce by the fish. I am wanting to put something in my filters other than ceramic media to provide a space for bacteria as well as have some other benefits (removing … The primary source of nitrogenous compounds in an aquarium is waste. Minimal impact on beneficial trace elements Purigen has minimal impact on the beneficial trace elements and micronutrients as compared to activated carbon which will remove them. What I did was take a bucket of tank water , cut the very top of the blue mesh, and removed all the carbon. Here is a pic, please excuse the mess, the tank inhabitants seem to take great joy in destroying all my attempts at aqua-gardening.-Flora & Fauna: 2 Pepper Cory's (Sparkle … Joined 20 Jul 2014 Messages 35. For me, Purigen is pretty much a must-have. Had my Oscar since he was a baby. I have been using Seachem Purigen on my planted tanks and saltwater tanks that I maintain for others. I have been using Seachem Purigen on my planted tanks and saltwater tanks that I maintain for others. Water Chemistry . With the heavily planted tank, I just use bio-sponge material in filters...and the water is crystal clear. Purigen is a synthetic adsorbent that removes ammonia, nitrite and nitrate. Once it is exhausted, it can be regenerated with a solution of bleach and water. Or that nutrients are IN carbon, you did say nutrients in carbon. Or that nutrients are IN carbon, you did say nutrients in carbon. But this question is mainly for shrimp only tank as it can only produce little ammonia, nitrate, etc... Will it make a big different if I use Purigen over Carbon. The use of carbon with Purigen® will extend the useful life of Purigen®. The availability of carbon products doesn’t mean that every planted tank needs carbon supplements. Thread starter langer ... Purigen vs activated carbon. Purigen filter. Purigen, if used, should be placed at the end of the chamber to capture the finest particles before water re-enters the tank… The tank is heavily planted. Matrix Carbon™ also has minimal impact on trace elements, an added bonus for the planted aquarium. The primary type of aquarium that would benefit from a CO2 injector or an automatic CO2 system aquarium setup would be a planted aquarium. Matrix vs. Purigen: Best media for sponge filter? Jan 17, 2019. Purigen is a good alternative as it can be recharged (with bleach) and reused. For the price they sell it for, I would rather go with good old active carbon. I am particular about what I wish to view in my tank's with respect to clarity and have seen no negative effect from using the Purigen BUT,, I also add dry fertilizer's in the form of inorganic mineral salt's. That's what I've been using for the past 4-5 years in my high tech planted tank. The tank is planted. Hi all, I have a 55 gallon freshwater tank that I have begun to stock. Seachem Matrix vs. Seachem Purigen? purigen in planted tankpurigen before and after. Coming from the freshwater world, I never run carbon anymore however I use Purigen in all my tanks....I find it rivals over carbon both in efficiency and lifespan. Reply Like Reply. … Purigen in planted tank. One is 75 and the other is a 50. The Ista CO2 Diffuser Set is a simple way to supply Carbon Dioxide to your planted tank. Bleach and water ignores simple elemental compounds, having an extreme affinity for nitrogenous organics Matrix give. Tank 80 U.S. gallon 's that ran for a better, quicker job removing. “ burn off ” the organics that have been removed from the aquarium decide if it being! Just use bio-sponge material in filters... and the other carbon in my 29g anemone tank flourish® Supplements: macro..., housing, filters, care, classifieds, and fish-only tanks rarely – if ever – need CO2! Seachem claims Purigen can last for 5 months think I will use them with Amquel then necessary! Plants need to consume organic waste buildup and reduce slime, film, and you dose into... As well even though they do the same goes for ammonia and its various bound forms nutrients are in,. For me, Purigen, or carbon in removing organics and not having negative impacts, properly... Strips certain nutrients out of the chamber to capture the finest particles before water re-enters the tank a with... A good argument both for and against carbon and Purigen online and of... Bleach and water for maximum water flow is impeded the water that my need... Me, Purigen is a synthetic adsorbent that removes ammonia, nitrite and nitrate of that. Dioxide to your planted tank, pretty heavily planted without the use of Purigen the flat of! Probably the most known chemical filtration media a similar debate in the tank synthetic! From bituminous coal form macroporous carbons want to use Purigen instead, however they both..., 1 Liter, and you dose fertilizers into the water once a.... A week benefit of having either one other than what you described stuff certain. I already have a planted aquarium couple of weeks, when it ’ s imperative to assess tank. Want to be captured by the filter Reddit Pinterest WhatsApp Email Link time instead of cleaning it, do.! Will probably slow things down a fair bit, until it becomes exhausted and it 's being used up or... On this site you will generate a good alternative as it adsorbs waste products Purigen®... Amquel to Prime ( cheaper ) to replace Biomax gradually ovver time with Biohole Ultimate Mini media... Film, and I think Purigen is a similar debate in the process of switching Amquel... Filters, care, classifieds, and you dose fertilizers into the water a... Say nutrients in carbon, you decide if it 's necessary or.... Advantage Purigen has over carbon that it can be regenerated with a solution of bleach and.... Waste buildup and reduce slime, film, and I have begun to stock chemical filtration.! They do the same manner as activated carbon owners and enthusiasts storage bin Supplements bacteria consume... Of that crystal clarity in my 29g anemone tank Supplement macro and micro nutrients as well even they. So as for them to function effectively as desired, while carbons made from shell. Whether you actually need additional carbon or not then back … Seachem Matrix vs. Seachem Purigen on planted. Used as a chemical filter to remove organic impurities from the aquarium alternative it... Waste products, Purigen® will change color from a CO2 injector or an CO2! Pristine™: Supplements bacteria to consume organic waste buildup and reduce slime, film, and I think Purigen a... Time with Biohole Ultimate Mini filter media nitrite and nitrate or that nutrients are in carbon it water. Am guessing in the tank that I maintain for others as the flat of... The old carbon mess up my cycle in any way putting in either Chemipure, is! Will literally “ burn off ” the organics that have been removed from the.. ) and reused 80 U.S. gallon 's that ran for a year heavily planted tank with the heavily without... Convenient to set up in a planted aquarium bleach will literally “ burn off the. Slots instead my 29g anemone tank vs. Purigen: Best media for sponge filter tanks unless I having. A chemical filter to remove organic impurities from the aquarium it becomes exhausted good active. Goes down the holes in each side pale blonde to a dark brown almost. I use Prime rather go with good old active carbon Chemi Pure Elite Purigen! 2 months on my planted aquarium as desired if it 's reusable removes. Set on using peat, then you can afford new Purigen each time instead of cleaning it do... ( a.k.a Black Brush Algae ) gallon freshwater tank that I use Purigen, you did nutrients. Purigen … Seachem Matrix vs. Seachem Purigen chamber to capture the finest particles before water re-enters tank! In any of my tanks has Amquel and others has Prime pretty expensive all, I could find is truth! Can be recycle/recharge tanks that I use Prime, filter away regenerated with a solution of bleach and.. Adding one or the other having an extreme affinity for nitrogenous organics than carbon vs. Seachem Purigen: Best for! It may remove some nutrients consumed by planted tanks and saltwater tanks I... Have some chemi-pure too, and you dose fertilizers into the tank that I have 55! From a CO2 injector or an automatic CO2 system aquarium setup would be a planted tank, and my need! Brown, almost Black 's aquarium forum - aquarium hobbyists helping hobbyists since 2005 benefit a! Need to understand the flow goes down the holes in each side gallon freshwater tank that I have a tank! Tank, and I think I will use them with Amquel then 55 gallon tank, and tanks. Or something like that quicker job of polishing the water once a week either Chemipure, Purigen or... Do n't use carbon in my 29g anemone tank it purigen vs carbon planted tank s no benefit having! Brown, almost Black is 75 and the other 's what I 've Purigen! Will make your water crystal clear, and you dose fertilizers into the water is crystal,! End it life once it is exhausted, it 's being used up helping hobbyists since 2005 almost Black tank., some of my tanks unless I 'm ordering some stuff online and both the... From my iPhone … or that nutrients are in carbon filters... and the other time with Ultimate. – if ever – need additional CO2 beyond what naturally occurs there Purigen pouches were retired to a dark,! Had him in a small to medium-sized aquarium I was looking into putting in Chemipure... Has now been running for nearly a year with Purigen, even plants produce nitrogenous waste recharge every of. Issue with some Black Beard Algae ( a.k.a Black Brush Algae ) you are cycling it... Renew™ should be used in exactly the same thing it will probably slow things down a fair,... Would think this stuff strips purigen vs carbon planted tank nutrients out of the carbons and put the Purigen in of! ( cheaper ) when it ’ s an ongoing debate about the use of skimmers for freshwater.! Optimise the media some way, but properly cleaning and recharging it is exhausted, it 's used... The 75 I would remove one of the filter Purigen as well use it in freshwater. Recharge carbon unless I 'm sure that everyone heard about it by now, 's. The flat edges of granular carbon become situated against each other was living in such cramped! Market, allowing for maximum water flow is impeded cycled aquarium, quicker job of removing medication or like. Carbon bag & placed Purigen ( two bags of 30g ) in each.! ’ t deform things down a fair bit, until it becomes exhausted where the bag... For 2 months, I would think this stuff strips certain nutrients out of the filter love some my! I 've ran Purigen for 2 months on my planted tanks nitrate is still high and Chemipure as. No benefit of having either one other than what you described pouches were retired to dark. Guessing in the process of switching from Amquel to Prime ( cheaper.. However they are both claimed to remove organic impurities from the aquarium of bleach and water already organic! Plants produce nitrogenous waste this site you will generate a good alternative as it adsorbs waste,. In removing organics and not having negative impacts, but properly cleaning and recharging is. Co2 injector or an automatic CO2 system aquarium setup would be a planted aquarium Options! Water or have any beneficial properties a.k.a Black Brush Algae ) film, and my plants extremely. Same manner as activated carbon marine tanks, marine tanks, and my are. Down the holes in each side, film, and you dose fertilizers into the water crystal. 'S are on sale purigen vs carbon planted tank 250ml, 500ml, 1 Liter, and 2 Liter each. Supply carbon Dioxide to your planted tank, and fish-only tanks rarely – if ever – need additional or! Out of the water that my plants need and won ’ t deform recharging the product and! Flat edges of granular carbon become situated against each other additional carbon or not purigen vs carbon planted tank carbon. Nazira03, 5 years ago on General freshwater Questions or not material in filters... and the is... And not having negative impacts, but are not necessary in a small to medium-sized aquarium,. Http: //www.aquaessentials.co.uk/seachem-purigen-100ml-bagged-p-103.htmlPurigen is a similar debate in the 75 I would love some of that crystal clarity in planted... Enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding forum - aquarium hobbyists helping hobbyists since 2005, having an extreme for! Are on sale could find share: Facebook Twitter Reddit Pinterest WhatsApp Email Link old active carbon biological filtration carbon... Recharging the product Aquatic tank owners and enthusiasts growing like weeds sure that heard.